Stevie Nicks: Writing the Breakup From Inside the Band
- Rhiannon (1975)
- Landslide (1975)
- Dreams (1977)
- Edge of Seventeen (1981)
- Stop Draggin' My Heart Around (1981)
In 1976, Stevie Nicks was writing songs about the end of her relationship with Lindsey Buckingham while Lindsey Buckingham sat a few feet away, playing guitar on the recordings. They weren't a normal couple splitting up and going their separate ways. They were two of the four songwriters in Fleetwood Mac, locked into a studio together in Sausalito for months, required to keep working, keep singing each other's words, keep finishing the record. Most breakups end with distance. This one ended with a mixing console between them and a tour still to play.
That's the story underneath Rumours, and it's worth understanding before anything else about how Nicks writes, because she wrote some of her most enduring songs directly out of that pressure, not around it.
Arriving with a name already half-written
Nicks was born Stephanie Nicks in Phoenix, Arizona in 1948, and got her nickname as a toddler who couldn't manage "Stephanie." She started writing songs young, on a guitar her grandfather gave her, and met Buckingham in high school in California. They played together for years, first in a band called Fritz, then as the duo Buckingham Nicks, before Mick Fleetwood heard Buckingham's guitar work on a demo and asked the pair to join Fleetwood Mac in 1975 as a unit. Nicks has said she was reluctant, worried about losing Buckingham as a partner if the band came between them. It did, eventually. Just not before it made them famous first.
Rhiannon, found in an airport paperback
"Rhiannon," from the band's self-titled 1975 album, came from a name Nicks liked before she knew what it meant. She picked up a novel called Triad by Mary Leader, about a woman possessed by another woman's spirit, and the name of that spirit stuck with her: "I got the name from a novel... I just thought the name was so pretty that I wanted to write something about a girl named Rhiannon." She built the character into "what I thought was an old Welsh witch," and only learned afterward that Rhiannon is an actual figure from Welsh mythology, a goddess associated with birds and horses. She'd written her way into a real legend by accident, then spent the next five decades performing the song as though she'd known that all along.
Landslide, written in five minutes at her parents' house
Not every Nicks song took long to arrive. "Landslide" came together in 1974, when she was twenty-six, staying with her parents in Phoenix and unsure whether the music career with Buckingham was going anywhere. Her father had gently suggested she consider going back to school. She picked up a guitar and wrote the song that became the answer, a plain, unguarded piece of self-questioning dressed up as nothing more than a folk melody: "'Landslide' I wrote on the guitar, and it's another one that I wrote in about five minutes." She's also been direct about who it was really addressed to: "I wrote it for Lindsey, for him, about him. It's dear to both of us because it's about us." A song about whether to keep going, written for and about the one person she'd have to keep going with.
Dreams, written alone in Sly Stone's old studio
By 1976, the band was recording Rumours at the Record Plant in Sausalito, and Nicks and Buckingham's relationship was actively ending in real time, in between takes. Nicks wandered into an unused studio next door that had once belonged to Sly Stone, a room with black velvet drapes and a sunken pit, sat down at a Fender Rhodes with a cassette recorder running, and wrote what became Fleetwood Mac's only number-one single. "I found a drum pattern, switched my little cassette player on and wrote 'Dreams' in about 10 minutes." The lyric answers Buckingham's side of the same breakup, which he'd already put into the album's other single, "Go Your Own Way." Two songs on the same record, arguing with each other, both true. It's one of the most well-documented instances in pop of a songwriter working through a relationship's ending while the person on the other end of it was still in the building. A version of that dynamic surfaces again on "Silver Springs," a song about Buckingham that Fleetwood Mac left off Rumours entirely, and that Nicks later performed staring directly at him on stage.
Grief arriving from two directions at once
"Edge of Seventeen," from her 1981 solo debut Bella Donna, came out of a single terrible week in December 1980: John Lennon was shot, and days later Nicks's uncle Jonathan died of cancer. She'd been writing a different song, about a younger relative, when both deaths landed on top of it, and the song reassembled itself around loss instead. "It became a song about violent death, which was very scary to me because at that point no one in my family had died." The title phrase itself came from mishearing something entirely unrelated, Tom Petty's wife saying she'd known Petty since she was "the age of seventeen," which Nicks misheard as "the edge of seventeen" and liked better than the truth. That's a small, telling habit of hers: catching a phrase that sounds mythic and building around it, whether or not it means what she thought.
Bella Donna and a song she didn't write herself
Bella Donna also gave Nicks her biggest hit outside Fleetwood Mac, "Stop Draggin' My Heart Around," a duet with Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers. Petty and guitarist Mike Campbell had written it for Petty's own album, decided it worked better sung from a woman's point of view, and handed it to Nicks instead. It became both acts' biggest single on the Hot 100. It's a useful footnote to her catalog of self-written, deeply personal songs: some of Nicks's best-known work is her interpreting somebody else's words, proof that a distinctive enough voice can make someone else's lyric sound like it was always hers.
A costume built on purpose, and a cost that was real
Nicks's stage image, the shawls, the platform boots, the tambourine spun and struck overhead while she turned in place, wasn't incidental. She's been plain about designing it deliberately: "Twenty years ago I sat down and decided that I would create a really wonderful image, an unforgettable image. And now I'm kind of stuck with it." She's also said the layers of chiffon served a second, more practical purpose, letting her hide inside them on stage while still reading as larger than life to the back row.
She's been equally direct about the years that image obscured. Cocaine use through the late seventies and eighties gave way, after she got sober, to an eight-year dependency on Klonopin, prescribed by a doctor in 1986 and, by her own account, more damaging than the drug it replaced: "It's addiction in a bottle." She's talked about getting herself out of both without crediting anyone else: "I managed to save myself... I saved me, nobody else saved me." It's not a detail that needs romanticizing, and Nicks doesn't romanticize it. She tells it as straight as she tells the story of any song.
What's worth taking from her career
Nicks became the first woman inducted twice into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, with Fleetwood Mac in 1998 and as a solo artist in 2019, a distinction that says as much about how long she kept writing at a high level as it does about the two eras she wrote it in. Her catalog holds two things that don't usually coexist so easily: some of the most nakedly autobiographical songwriting of her generation, and a stage persona built almost entirely out of myth and costume. She never hid the second thing to protect the first. She wrote "Dreams" ten feet from the person it was about and let the record come out anyway. If you're sitting on a song you're afraid to finish because the person it's about might hear it, or might still be in the room, Nicks's catalog is the argument for writing it down regardless, and for finding someone who can help you turn it into something that lasts longer than the moment that caused it. If that's the kind of collaborator you need, go find them.
Sources: Britannica, Rock & Roll Hall of Fame, GRAMMY.com, American Songwriter, Far Out Magazine, Men's Journal
Write like Stevie Nicks?
Stevie Nicks is tagged Mythic / Surreal here. Mythic / Surreal writing draws on folklore, ritual and dream-logic rather than realism, favouring archetypes over named characters.
Find out more about Mythic / Surreal lyrics